How to file a criminal complaint in Italy?

Need to report a crime in Italy? This comprehensive guide explains everything about filing a criminal complaint (“denuncia penale”) in Italy, whether you’re an Italian citizen, resident or tourist.

Filing a criminal complaint in Italy is a fundamental right that allows victims and witnesses to report crimes to the authorities and seek justice through the Italian criminal justice system. Understanding the proper procedures, required documentation, and legal distinctions between different types of complaints is essential for ensuring your case is handled effectively. This guide provides step-by-step instructions for filing criminal complaints in Italy, covering both denuncia (criminal report) and querela (formal complaint) procedures.

Types of Criminal Complaints in Italy

Reati Perseguibili d’Ufficio – Crimes prosecuted automatically by the state once reported through denuncia, including theft, assault, fraud, drug offenses, and violent crimes that affect public order
Reati Perseguibili a Querela di Parte – Crimes that require victim’s formal complaint (querela) to proceed, such as defamation, minor assault, stalking, harassment, and violations requiring victim’s explicit consent for prosecution
Istanza (Request for Investigation) – Used for crimes prosecuted only upon victim’s request, including private violence, threat, and certain privacy violations
Referto (Medical Report) – Mandatory report filed by medical professionals when treating injuries from suspected criminal acts
Rapporto (Police Report) – Official report filed by law enforcement officers who witness or discover criminal activity during their duties
Esposto (Information Report) – Informal report to bring suspicious activities to authorities’ attention without formal accusation
Costituzione di Parte Civile – Procedure to join criminal proceedings as civil party to seek damages compensation
Opposizione a Decreto Penale – Opposition to penal decree when disagreeing with imposed sanctions

Case Study 1: Sexual Assault (Reato Perseguibile d’Ufficio)

Sara is a victim of sexual assault and reports the crime to the police. Sexual assault is classified as a reato perseguibile d’ufficio, meaning the state automatically prosecutes once the crime is reported through denuncia. The investigation proceeds regardless of Sara’s wishes to continue – she cannot withdraw the complaint once filed. The prosecutor has the duty to pursue the case in the public interest, even if the victim later decides she doesn’t want to proceed with the case.

Case Study 2: Defamation (Reato Perseguibile a Querela di Parte)

Paolo discovers his former business partner posted false accusations about him on social media, damaging his professional reputation. Since defamation requires victim consent for prosecution, Paolo must file a querela within 3 months of discovering the posts. He retains the right to withdraw the complaint later if he reaches a private settlement with his former partner.

Where to File a Criminal Complaint

Carabinieri Stations – Available throughout Italy with jurisdiction over all types of crimes, often preferred for serious offenses and in smaller towns
Polizia di Stato (State Police) – Major police force with specialized divisions for cybercrime, financial crimes, and immigration-related offenses
Procura della Repubblica (Public Prosecutor’s Office) – Direct filing with prosecutors for complex cases or when specific expertise is required
Guardia di Finanza – Specialized for financial crimes, tax evasion, customs violations, and economic offenses
Online Platforms – Some police forces offer digital complaint systems for specific crime types like cybercrime and fraud
Municipal Police – Limited jurisdiction for minor offenses and administrative violations within city boundaries
Polizia Postale – Specialized unit for internet crimes, online fraud, cyberstalking, and digital evidence cases
Airport/Border Police – For crimes occurring at borders, airports, or involving immigration violations

Is Criminal Complaint the Best Way to Obtain Justice?

Filing a criminal complaint is not always the most effective path to justice, and many disputes don’t involve criminal law at all. Criminal proceedings focus on punishment and public order, while victims often seek compensation, resolution, or prevention of future harm. Some issues fall under civil law and require different legal approaches to achieve satisfactory outcomes.

Civil law remedies may be more appropriate for contract disputes, property damage, employment issues, family matters, and many business conflicts. Civil proceedings can provide monetary compensation, injunctive relief, and faster resolution than criminal cases. Additionally, the burden of proof in civil cases is lower than in criminal proceedings, making successful outcomes more likely in certain situations.

Many situations benefit from a combined approach using both criminal and civil procedures. For example, theft victims can file criminal complaints while simultaneously pursuing civil action for damages. Professional legal advice is essential to determine the best strategy, as choosing the wrong approach can limit your options and delay resolution. Always consult with a qualified lawyer before deciding whether criminal complaint, civil action, or alternative dispute resolution methods best serve your interests.

Who Can File a Criminal Complaint in Italy

Crime Victims – Direct victims of criminal acts have the primary right to file complaints and can choose between denuncia or querela depending on the crime type
Legal Representatives – Parents, guardians, or legal representatives can file complaints on behalf of minors, incapacitated persons, or those unable to act independently
Witnesses – Any person who witnessed a crime can file a denuncia to report criminal activity, even if they weren’t directly harmed
Heirs and Family Members – In cases of death, heirs can continue existing complaints or file new ones for crimes against deceased persons
Legal Entities – Companies, associations, and organizations can file complaints through their legal representatives for crimes affecting their interests
Public Officials – Certain public officials have mandatory reporting obligations and must file reports when they become aware of specific crimes
Medical Professionals – Doctors and healthcare workers must file referto when treating injuries suspected to result from criminal acts
Third Parties – Anyone can file an esposto to bring suspicious activities to authorities’ attention, though this doesn’t constitute formal accusation

Why Filing a Criminal Complaint is Important

Filing a criminal complaint serves multiple crucial purposes within the Italian legal system. It formally notifies authorities of criminal activity, initiating the investigation process and potentially preventing further crimes. Many crimes in Italy have statute of limitations periods, making prompt reporting essential to preserve your legal rights and ensure perpetrators can be prosecuted.

Criminal complaints create an official record that can be used in civil proceedings for damages compensation. They also provide statistical data that helps law enforcement allocate resources and identify crime patterns in specific areas. For victims, filing a complaint can provide psychological closure and demonstrate that society takes their suffering seriously.

Under Italian law, certain professionals have mandatory reporting obligations, and failing to report specific crimes can result in legal consequences. Additionally, some insurance claims require police reports, making criminal complaints necessary for financial recovery. The complaint also establishes your legal standing to participate in criminal proceedings as parte civile (civil party) to seek monetary damages.

How to File a Criminal Complaint

Important: Time limits apply to certain types of complaints. Querela must typically be filed within 3 months of discovering the crime or the perpetrator’s identity.

Choose the Correct Complaint Type: Determine whether your situation requires a denuncia or querela based on the crime type. Consult with a criminal lawyer if unsure, as filing the wrong type can delay or compromise your case.

Gather Required Documentation: Collect all evidence including photographs, medical reports, witness statements, receipts, contracts, and any other relevant documents. Organize evidence chronologically and make copies for your records.

Select the Appropriate Authority: File with Carabinieri, Polizia di Stato, or directly with the Procura della Repubblica (Public Prosecutor’s Office). Choose the most convenient location or one with expertise in your crime type.

Prepare Your Statement: Write a detailed account of events including dates, times, locations, people involved, and specific actions. Be factual and avoid emotional language or personal opinions about guilt or innocence.

Complete the Filing Process: Present yourself with valid identification, provide your detailed statement, submit supporting evidence, and answer any clarifying questions from officers. Request a copy of your complaint for your records.

Follow Up on Your Case: Stay informed about investigation progress, provide additional information if requested, and consider legal representation to protect your interests throughout the criminal proceedings.

Consider Civil Action: Evaluate whether to join criminal proceedings as parte civile or file separate civil lawsuit for damages compensation, consulting with your lawyer about the best strategy for your situation.

Get Expert Legal Assistance for Your Criminal Complaint

Filing a criminal complaint in Italy requires precision and knowledge of complex legal procedures. Don’t risk compromising your case by navigating the system alone. Contact Alfredo Esposito today for expert guidance on criminal complaints and procedures. Our experienced legal team will help you determine the correct complaint type, gather necessary evidence, and ensure your rights are fully protected throughout the process. We provide consultation services starting from €200-€500 per hour plus applicable taxes, following Decreto Ministeriale 55/2014 standards. Call our office or schedule a consultation online to discuss your criminal complaint and explore your legal options for seeking justice and compensation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What’s the difference between reati perseguibili d’ufficio and reati perseguibili a querela di parte?

A: Reati perseguibili d’ufficio are crimes prosecuted automatically by the state once reported (like theft, fraud, assault), while reati perseguibili a querela di parte require the victim’s formal complaint to proceed (like defamation, harassment). The victim can withdraw querela complaints but not denuncia reports.

Q: Can I file a criminal complaint online in Italy?

A: Some Italian police forces offer online complaint systems for certain types of crimes, but most criminal complaints must be filed in person at police stations or prosecutor’s offices. Contact your local authorities to check available options for your specific situation.

Q: Do I need a lawyer to file a criminal complaint in Italy?

A: While not legally required to file a complaint, having a lawyer is highly recommended to ensure proper procedures, protect your rights, and maximize chances of successful prosecution. Legal representation becomes essential if you join proceedings as parte civile.

Q: What happens after I file a criminal complaint in Italy?

A: After filing, the Public Prosecutor (PM) reviews your complaint and decides whether to open an investigation, dismiss the case, or request additional information. You’ll receive updates on the investigation progress and may be called to provide additional testimony.

Q: Can I withdraw a criminal complaint in Italy?

A: You can only withdraw a querela (formal complaint), not a denuncia. Withdrawal must be done formally and may have time limits. Some crimes cannot be withdrawn once proceedings begin, especially if there’s significant public interest.

Q: How long do I have to file a criminal complaint in Italy?

A: Time limits vary by crime type. Querela must generally be filed within 3 months of discovering the crime or perpetrator. Denuncia has longer periods, but prompt filing is always recommended to preserve evidence and strengthen your case.

Q: What documents do I need to file a criminal complaint?

A: You need valid identification, detailed written statement of events, any evidence (photos, medical reports, receipts), witness information, and relevant documentation. Organize everything chronologically and bring copies for authorities.

Q: Can foreigners file criminal complaints in Italy?

A: Yes, foreigners have the same rights as Italian citizens to file criminal complaints. You may need translation services for documents and statements. Embassy or consulate assistance may be available for serious crimes involving foreign nationals.

Table of Contents